Park Avenue Pet Center

Since my move to the this area in 2006, the Pet Center',s customer service has always been quick, courteous and informative. The owners, Carolyn and Joe have always kept their store in fine condition and fully stocked with the latest in pet supplies. If you need a fish or supply ordered, they will do everything they can to get it for you quickly and for a fair price. They are always upfront and honest about the item you show interest in. For example, if you want to purchase a fish, they always make sure any fish you intend to keep them with are compatible and they let you know the care required. My wife and I highly recommend Carolyn and Joe's Pet Center in Rutherford, NJ.

Nice customer atmosphere, joe is very helpful with what customers need. Nice local pet store.

Nice people, very helpful. They have the best dog treats. I can always find a fun toy for my grandpup. They're local, parking is good, etc. I recommend the Park Avenue Pet Center in Rutherford.

Great local place to shop. Owners are very friendly and nice. They will help you with all your needs, and will inform you if/when items that you want arrive. Shop has fish and supplies, reptile supplies, dog/cat supplies and other items along with live crickets and a variety of live fish. There is also an area in the back, full with pet food. They carry hard to come by "Primal" brand dog food that my small breed is crazy about. Prices are fair. Would highly recommend shopping here.

Store doesn't have any Fresh/Live worms for Reptile, Birds or Fish as of July 16th 2025